Faithful Politics

Being faithful with our politics, not political with our faith.

America, Jesus, Freedom: Patriotism & the Christian

Photo by Patti Perret/ Warner Bros

“America, Jesus, freedom!”

These words are heard at the very beginning of the new Will Ferrell comedy, The Campaign. Ferrell plays a Republican congressman in the fictional 14th district of North Carolina. When asked by his campaign manager exactly what this slogan means, he admits that he has no idea, but the people sure love it when he says it.

While The Campaign is, of course, a fictional Hollywood comedy, it is meant to be a satirical take on the actual state of the current political theater in the United States. When viewed in this light, I believe the movie actually brings out a lot of important points, like this idea of American patriotism- or more accurately, American nationalism- and its connection to American Christianity.

From the 2009 publishing of “The American Patriot’s Bible” (yes, it really exists…) to the constant barrage of pseudo-Christian messages from our political candidates, and the endless argument over whether or not the founding fathers of our nation were evangelical Christians in the way that we would define that today, it is obvious that there is a relationship between patriotism and Christianity in the U.S.

I believe that we have to be extremely careful about making connections between our feelings towards the country that we live in and our faith as followers of Jesus Christ. We must guard against allowing our faith to become wrapped up in patriotism, and vice-versa, against wrapping our patriotism in the Christian faith.

One of the most striking- and unsettling- personal experiences I have had that displayed the unhealthy connection between patriotism and Christianity occurred during a church service on the weekend of the 4th of July a couple years ago. At the time, my husband and I were attending a large church that had a very “seeker-friendly” emphasis, and they held special weekend services every few months that were specifically aimed at drawing in new people. They often scheduled these services to occur on holiday weekends, like this Independence Day-themed service.

When the curtains came up, we saw that the entire stage was decked out in a patriotic theme, with several American flags and other red, white and blue décor. “America the Beautiful” was sung as the final “worship” song, before a video was shown that highlighted the military and leadership achievements of the service’s special guest, a former military officer who was a Christian. Then, an enormous American flag back drop was rolled out on stage as the guest speaker and one of the pastors came out to begin the interview. Admittedly, it was at this point that my husband and I stood up and left the service.

I want to emphasize that I certainly do not believe it is wrong to thank God for our nation, or even to be proud to live in America. The United States is, in many ways, a special and unique country that allows us freedoms that are entirely unavailable in many, many countries around the world. However, our allegiance to our faith must always be infinitely stronger that our allegiance to anything else, including the nation we live in.

Recently, some friends and I got into a discussion about outsourcing and its effect on jobs in America. One of my friends brought up a very compelling point: why is it that we, as Americans, seem to have a problem with people in other countries having jobs? Why do we believe that only Americans “deserve” to have jobs? While my own primary concern with outsourcing jobs is the human rights violations that occur in many of the nations that we outsource jobs to, I recognize that most Americans are less concerned with that and more concerned with jobs being lost here in the States. This is certainly a complex issue in and of itself, but it’s important to recognize this element of nationalism- a sense that “my nation is better than yours” permeates American thinking.

This attitude is strikingly different than the one we see in the New Testament. In Colossians 3:11, Paul writes, “Here there is no Greek or Jew, circumcised or uncircumcised, barbarian, Scythian, slave or free, but Christ is all, and is in all.” Christianity is a faith that levels the playing field for all. As American Christians, we must remember this truth and be sure we are living it out in every area of our lives- from the church to the public square.

Bookmark and Share
Tagged as: , , , , , ,

1 Comment

  1. Thank you, Lisa! It irritates me to no end when Christians blend nationalism with our faith. Your 4th of July experience at the large church is truly disturbing. Imagine if the early Christians waved the Roman standard in their gatherings and decorated their meeting houses with decorations honoring the Roman empire whilst singing songs of praise to Rome. It’s simply not something they would think of doing… or in a modern context, it’s not something that the church in China would do either. I even get antsy when I see American flags in church sanctuaries.

    Like you, I don’t hate America. I rather like the country I live in. I just don’t see Jesus blending faith and patriotism, and so I don’t think we should either. I would probably even take it further and say that not only should “our allegiance to our faith … always be infinitely stronger than our allegiance to anything else, including the nation we live in,” but perhaps we should have no other allegiances except to Christ. Paul wrote that now, in Christ, “there is no Greek or Jew, circumcised or uncircumcised, barbarian, Scythian, slave or free” (Col 3:11). I think that it is interesting that Paul does not say “there is BOTH Greek and Jew,” but “there is NO Greek and Jew.”

    All too often we American Christians try to affirm our identity in Jesus while holding onto our identity as Americans. Would it be so bad if we, like the early Christians and the Anabaptists, refused to pledge our allegiance to anyone or anything except Christ? If a house divided cannot stand (cf. Mark 3:24-25), then perhaps we should not have allegiance both to our Lord and our country.

Leave a Response